Broken and Booming: The State of College Sports
Thank you for joining us this Saturday morning.
Today we are taking an in-depth look at the passion, attention, excitement – and spending, that surround college sports in North Carolina.
According to a 2023 UNC System economic impact report, college athletics “have a cascading impact that boosts economic activity and supports employment in a range of industries.” The report puts the annual contribution to the state’s economy at $1.13 billion, and that figure does not include North Carolina’s private colleges and universities. Private institutions such as Duke, Wake Forest and Elon also have strong athletics programs that add another significant layer to the state’s college-sports economy and culture.
College athletics are also an economic development driver according to site selection experts where sports and entertainment are a major factor in the decision-making process. In markets like Greenville, Burlington, Winston-Salem, and Boone, college sports can be particularly impactful.
Beyond the numbers, there’s a social benefit, too. “Athletic programs help generate volunteerism and community service, attract donations into the institution, and enhance social cohesion through establishing a unifying force for the communities they represent,” the report explains.
Conversations from work meetings to family dinners often touch on the latest developments in college football and basketball. College sports and conference rivalries are deeply embedded in the North Carolina culture, providing social, economic, and reputational dividends to the families, businesses, and universities that operate here. To protect these rivalries, some states have mandated that certain games be played.
That also means there’s much that can be lost in an ever-evolving university athletics landscape. That risk of loss is not just borne by a college or university, it is a risk to our state and our culture.
How we got here
In 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously ruled in NCAA v. Alston that the NCAA was not immune from antitrust law. Shortly thereafter, the NCAA adopted an interim policy permitting college athletes to profit from their name, image, and likeness.
A federal court-approved settlement last year established the regime that exists today: participating Division I schools may spend up to $21.3 million this year to compensate athletes directly, with the cap increasing over time. At many major athletics programs, football and men’s basketball are the primary profit-generating sports, and they receive the largest shares of direct athlete compensation. The settlement deferred but did not conclude the debate over whether college athletes should be considered employees and the added institutional expense that would come with that.
That cap only covers what schools pay athletes directly. Name, image, and likeness (NIL) deals from outside businesses and donor-backed collectives come on top of it, and that’s where much of the money now moves. Top college football programs are spending about $40 million on their rosters this season, roughly double the cap. A new College Sports Commission reviews any outside deal over $600 for a legitimate business purpose and fair-market pay. Since launching in June 2025, it has cleared more than 56,500 deals worth about $775 million and another 2,877 worth about $177 million were submitted but not cleared. Schools paid athletes another $1.77 billion directly through revenue sharing in the settlement’s first year.
The cost on campus
There are complex downstream effects of those policies. For example, should athlete payment negotiations at public institutions be shielded from public records laws? How much athletics-generated revenue should universities be willing to spend on sports as a whole, and player compensation in particular, when the purpose of a college or university is to educate, first and foremost? Should the public be able to wager on the performance of an individual athlete? And should public and private colleges share in the revenue received by the state from gambling on their sports?
At public universities, those pressures also raise questions about transparency, institutional spending and affordability. At a recent UNC System Board of Governors meeting, System officials reported that students paid more than $136 million in mandatory athletics fees last year, and no System school covered its athletics expenses with athletics-generated revenue alone. The burden varies sharply by campus: athletics fees run from $232 at NC State to more than $900 at some smaller institutions.
UNC System policy bars student fees from funding athlete revenue sharing or NIL payments, but places no cap on campus support for athletics, a gap System officials have flagged for possible guardrails. The new costs are already showing up. UNC-Chapel Hill ran a roughly $15 million athletics deficit in fiscal 2025, before its first full year of revenue sharing.
NC State projected a shortfall of nearly $18 million in the first year of revenue sharing. Director of Athletics Boo Corrigan says his department balanced its budget, crediting the Wolfpack Club, but expects to “face a deficit again this year.”
Those pressures are not limited to public institutions: Duke and Wake Forest face the same ACC revenue gap, athlete-compensation rules, and transfer environment under different institutional funding models. These pressures also impact the non-revenue sports such as soccer, lacrosse, field hockey, golf, tennis, and others, which have brought multiple national championships home to North Carolina.
The ACC’s revenue gap
The ACC, meanwhile, is growing rapidly but still faces a structural revenue disadvantage. Commissioner Jim Phillips says league revenue has increased 43 percent over the past five years and is projected to approach $1 billion, while sponsorship revenue has more than doubled since the conference moved to Charlotte. Yet media rights still account for roughly 85 percent of the revenue conferences distribute, and the ACC remains well behind the Big Ten and SEC in annual payouts to member schools. On average, Big Ten schools received about $33 million more in conference revenue than ACC schools, while SEC schools received about $25 million more. The difference will likely remain until the current ACC media rights agreement is improved. It is set to expire in 2036 unless addressed sooner. As this season has shown, more money does not guarantee success on the field or a happy fan base and the power conferences want teams who can add market share whether or not they succeed on the field.
Conference distributions are only one part of the financial picture, and the overall size of athletics departments varies widely. Ohio State reported a record $336 million in athletics revenue in fiscal year 2025, while Alabama reported $267 million. UNC-Chapel Hill generated about $173 million and NC State about $142 million. But the comparison is not uniform: Minnesota, for example, reported about $164 million in revenue, illustrating that conference affiliation alone does not determine an athletics department’s total financial resources.
The transfer portal
And we haven’t even broached one of the most frustrating recent developments for college sports fans: the never-ending carousel that is the “transfer portal.” Under pressure from multiple lawsuits, in 2024, the NCAA expanded immediate transfer eligibility, allowing Division I athletes who meet academic requirements to compete right away at a new school even if they’ve transferred before. Combined with compensation offers from competing programs, that means large portions of team rosters can change from year to year with constant free agency. It’s almost impossible for fans to keep up.
Put it all together, and “chaos” is the word that comes to mind first when taking stock of the past several years in college athletics. UNC System President Peter Hans described the landscape well: “There’s a key paradox here, because most people would agree the college athletics model has never been more broken. And yet, it has never been more popular.”
Congress steps in
The U.S. Senate on September 28 passed the Protect College Sports Act by a 77-22 margin. The measure seeks to impose some level of order to the chaos, including a limited antitrust exemption for the NCAA.
The bill would increase the per-school maximum for player compensation while hardening rules and enforcement. It also allows just one transfer for a player across five years of eligibility, and caps agent fees. What’s more, schools could not cut certain sports or funding for women’s and non-revenue programs. On NIL, deals with boosters and collectives would have to serve a valid business purpose and pay in line with comparable non-athletes, and conflicting state NIL laws would be preempted.
Lastly, the bill caps the largest conferences at 20 member schools and imposes a three-year gap for schools that switch conferences. During that gap, schools would be “independent” from any conference.
The latter provision elicited pushback from four ACC schools, including UNC. In a letter to House lawmakers, the schools asked that the 20-school cap be increased to 22, and the three-year purgatory be eliminated.
During Senate consideration, lawmakers amended certain provisions of the bill to favor the SEC and Big 10 and high-market schools to gain their support. The House has yet to take up the bill. With only weeks left in the lame-duck session and new majorities taking over both chambers in January, its prospects are far from certain. If the House makes changes, then it must go back to the Senate for concurrence. If the two chambers can’t agree on final language before year’s end, then they’ll have to start over next year.
What’s at stake for NC
North Carolina’s college sports identity was built on things that money alone can’t buy: rivalries between schools a short drive apart, a basketball tradition that put Chapel Hill, Durham, and Raleigh on the national map, and packed stadiums in Winston-Salem, Boone, and Greenville that help keep local economies humming.
Over the past five years, every development has pushed toward a system that rewards whoever can spend the most. Federal legislation won’t fix all of that, but the alternative is more of what we have now.
The Board of Governors is already examining student fees, institutional support and the long-term sustainability of athletics spending for North Carolina’s public colleges and universities. North Carolina’s congressional delegation is also weighing in on the federal framework that will shape conference realignment, athlete compensation and transfer rules. At the same time, the ACC is generating record revenue and expanding its economic footprint in Charlotte and across the state. The challenge is finding a framework that keeps North Carolina institutions competitive and maintains the attractiveness of our rivalries and college sports culture, without losing sight of affordability, accountability, and the broader mission of higher education.
Recent Articles
Broken and Booming: The State of College Sports
Thank you for joining us this Saturday morning. Today we are taking an in-depth look at the passion, attention, excitement – and spending, that surround college sports in North Carolina. According to a 2023 UNC System economic impact report, college athletics “have a cascading impact that boosts economic activity and supports employment in a range of…
After the Earthquake: What a Historic Election Means for N.C.
Thank you for joining us this Saturday morning. A 10.0-Richter-scale earthquake struck the American political landscape this week. Today we assess the fallout and touch on the potential political and policy implications. We’ll get right to it. *** Washington Congressional Democrats will enter 2027 with the second-largest net gain in the House of Representatives since…
Is a wave coming? What North Carolina’s early-vote numbers actually show
Aqua-themed metaphors abound this time of year. Is it a wave? A tsunami? A king tide?! The answer is that nobody really knows yet. Fortunately, North Carolina has an extended early-voting period, giving us fresh data each morning to examine who’s already casting ballots. I’ve been tracking these numbers during the 5 a.m. hour, nearly…